[Madison]

I saw this from bbPress sites. Even if your theme doesn’t link /reply/ anywhere Google will still find it sometimes from your sitemap.xml

There is no fix after many years, but you can noindex using Nginx:

location ~ ^(.*)/reply/$ {
        try_files $uri $uri/ /index.php?$args;
        set $robots "noindex, nofollow, nosnippet, noarchive";
}

[Jean]

SlickStack includes this by default

https://github.com/littlebizzy/slickstack/blob/master/modules/nginx/sites/production.txt

[Michelle]

bbPress gang were talking about this several years ago with no fix:

Reply pages & SEO issues

[Jesse]

that thread is like 10 years old and they never fixed this problem?

[Author]

Posts